Pizza Near 171 E 212th St: Euclid's Best Slices and Delivery Spots

Pizza might be the most reliable test of a neighborhood's everyday livability, and the stretch of Euclid around 171 E 212th St passes it easily. The city's independent pizzerias cluster on E 222nd St, the delivery corridors run right along Lake Shore Boulevard, and a couple of cross-border classics round out the list. Here is where to order.

The E 222nd St Pizza Row

Three independent shops sit within a block or two of one another on E 222nd St, about half a mile from the house. Carmella's Pizza Bazaar at 804 E 222nd St (216-261-1130) is a family-owned institution serving Euclid since 1957, known for fresh ingredients, a strong crust, and a long list of pizza styles, and it tops Restaurant Guru's Euclid rankings at about 4.4 stars across its listings. Guys Pizza Co. at 859 E 222nd St (216-797-4897) is a Northeast Ohio family pizzeria that started in Euclid in 2001 and has grown to nine locations; it builds hand-tossed pies with dough made daily, fresh toppings, and a homemade sauce, and it sells by the slice (public listings note slices in the $1.50 to $3 range), plus wings, burgers, and salads. Pizza Now at 810 E 222nd St (216-261-8888) is the quick-serve option, with pizza, chicken, and loaded fries ready when you walk in and pickup or delivery for customized orders.

Lake Shore Blvd: The Delivery Corridor

If the order is coming to the door, the big names line Lake Shore Boulevard just minutes east of the Edgecliff lakefront: Papa Johns at 22370 Lake Shore Blvd (216-777-8015), Marco's at 22800 Lake Shore Blvd (216-289-5455), and Domino's at 23910 Lake Shore Blvd (216-815-0911). For a quick pickup, Little Caesars sits at 22674 Shore Center Dr and Pizza Hut at 22455 Shore Center Dr, both a few minutes away. And for a pizza dinner with a lakefront view, Beach Club Bistro at 21939 Lake Shore Blvd does sheet pizzas and family-size pasta packs, giving the same block a sit-down alternative to delivery.

Just Over the Cleveland Line

Two neighborhood favorites sit right on the Euclid border. Congin's Pizza at 18812 Nottingham Rd (216-481-4585) is a long-running institution of the Nottingham and Collinwood area, a few minutes from the E 212th St corridor. Primoz Pizza at 683 E 200th St (216-452-7100) is on the eastern edge of Cleveland right against Euclid, an easy carryout stop for anyone heading up E 200th. Both give the neighborhood a slightly wider pizza map than its city limits alone would suggest.

What This Means for Buyers

For buyers, the practical picture is a neighborhood where pizza night never requires planning: an independent slice run, a sheet pizza pickup by the lake, or a delivery order from one of three national chains are all within minutes of 171 E 212th St. When we walk the neighborhood with buyers, the E 222nd St cluster of longtime local shops is one of the quiet details that makes the lakefront feel like a settled community rather than a summer-only address.

Pizza shop names, addresses, and phone numbers above were checked September 18, 2026 against each restaurant's website and public directory listings; Carmella's rating and Guys Pizza history are per Restaurant Guru and public business listings. Menus, hours, and prices change, so confirm with the shop before you order.